Episode 99SN: What you “know” about Motherhood is probably wrong: Chelsea’s story, Part I

This is episode 99 of the podcast, and next week is the 100th episode. it seems a totally fitting tribute, for a podcast dedicated to changing the conversation about this transformation, to have a guest whose profound book is all about debunking our most socially potent beliefs about what defines a mother and where they came from (spoiler alert: they don’t come from rigorous scientific examination, at best I’d call them science adjacent).

My guest shares the experiences she had in pregnancy and postpartum that inspired her to write this book which so powerfully dispels so many myths around mothers and motherhood. While she was talking, all I could think was: why weren’t you whispering this in my ear when I was pregnant? This could have changed how I thought about lots of aspects of my postpartum, although I’m grateful to overturn some of my most oppressive beliefs; hopefully she can change how you think of this period.

Here’s Chelsea’s book: Mother Brain: How Neuroscience is Rewriting the Story of Parenthood

Audio Transcript

Chelsea: 

This idea that maternal instinct is innate and is automatic and really distinctly female. We generally talk about the scientific idea but it really was rooted in moral and religious ideas of womanhood and motherhood that were then written to scientific theories, particularly through evolutionary theory. And Charles Darwin talked about maternal instinct as the very thing that made men superior to women that were designed to care for one another and men were designed to compete with one another and that’s how they obtained higher eminence he said in all things because that competition,

paulette  0:52  

Welcome to war stories from the womb. This is a show that shares true experiences giving birth to help shift the cultural narrative away from the glossy transition to a more realistic one. It also celebrates the incredible resilience and strength it takes to create another person or release that new person from their body, into the world. I’m your host, Paulette Kamenecka, I’m a writer and an economist  and a mother of two girls. And boy, did I struggle with this transition. 

This is episode 99 of the podcast, and next week is the 100th episode. It seems a totally fitting tribute for a podcast dedicated to changing the conversation around this transformation, to have a guest whose profound book is all about our most socially potent beliefs about what defines a mother and where those beliefs in my guest here’s the experiences she had a pregnancy and postpartum that inspired her to write this book, which so powerfully dispels so many myths around mothers and motherhood. While she was talking, all I could think was, why weren’t you whispering this in my ear when I was pregnant? This could have changed how I thought about lots of aspects of my postpartum although I’m grateful to overturn some of my most oppressive beliefs even now. Hopefully, she can change how you think is what follows is part one of our conversation. 

Today we’re lucky to have Chelsea Conaboy on the show, the author of Mother Brain, how neuroscience is rewriting the story of parenthood and this is an amazing book and if I had to give a synopsis I would say Santa is not real and either as the Easter Bunny and everything you thought you knew about parenting is wrong. Thank you. Good night. We’ll get to the details. We’ll talk about me it’s a fascinating read. But first of all start with your story because it feels like from the book that kind of motivated your interest in this subject. 

 

Chelsea: Absolutely. 

 

Paulette: Okay, good. So we’ll start with you first. So I know from reading the book that you are one of three. It’s right. 

 

Chelsea: Yeah, I’m the youngest. 

 

Paulette: And I’m wondering if you think that experience of growing up with siblings made you think you want to have a family or why did you know you want to have family?

 

chelsea  2:59  

I don’t ever remember it being a question really. Honestly, I grew up in a pretty close family, also very conservative suburban family and we were Catholic and it was just kind of always an assumption that I that I would be a mom but externally probably but internally to I was I kind of always assumed I would.

 

paulette  3:23  

Excellent. Okay, well, that’s a smoother path to actually being one. I think, you know, in some sense, right?

 

chelsea  3:29  

Probably, I guess so. I mean, I think there are different bumps for everyone, but I think

 

Paulette:  totally 

 

Chelsea: that sort of assumption also, I think partly set me up with false expectations about what it would be like to become one for sure.

 

paulette  3:43  

Oh, yes. And obviously you’re not alone. Yeah. So let’s fast forward to the time of your life when you think you’re gonna have kids. So do you get pregnant easily?

 

chelsea  3:54  

Yes, we did get pregnant easily, which was a relief. We were trying I was at a very what I would consider stable point in my life. I had my husband and I had been married for about a year we had a good job. I was more financially stable than I had bad at any point in my adult life. We wanted to have kids and we were trying and then luckily we got pregnant.

 

paulette  4:18  

And you I’m assuming you found out what’s like a home

 

chelsea  4:21  

kit or how did you did? Yes. Yeah, absolutely. So

 

paulette  4:25  

how did that go? Yeah, it

 

chelsea  4:27  

was it was good. i My husband and I were getting ready to go to a drive in movie and packing a picnic. And and we’re going to bring some mixed drinks, I think and I was feeling just a little funny. And went and took a test and came out and said I’ll make my non alcoholic. It was a really happy moment.

 

paulette  4:50  

That’s awesome. Yeah, that seems like you’re pretty attuned to your body to recognize that something feels off and I’ll take a pregnancy test.

 

chelsea  4:58  

Yeah, I mean, I think it was top of mind. Something felt off. And I mean, I think my boobs were more painful than usual. And they they felt bloated and and it but it was already top of mind because because we had been trying that was something we were talking a lot about. So yeah, I had the test in hands and I was sort of thinking much they take

 

paulette  5:20  

Yeah, awesome. That’s awesome. Yeah. So what’s the pregnancy like?

 

chelsea  5:26  

So overall, for most of the pregnancy, most of the pregnancy went very well to think back here a little bit. So I was working full time at a newspaper through my pregnancy and my husband and I both worked at the same newspaper and we were living in an apartment in Portland, Maine, and we were house hunting at the same time. So the house hunt piece was a stressful part of the pregnancy because we’re under contract at one point and then it fell through on the seller side and it just was some ups and downs. Pregnancy itself physically. It was like what I now kind of understand to be a kind of mild experience. From what I’ve heard from others, I had some morning sickness, but nothing awful. I felt good in my second trimester. We let’s go

 

paulette  6:14  

slowly there for one second. So the morning sickness, does that mean you’re throwing up at work or you just no

 

chelsea  6:19  

nauseous? Let me see no. And I wasn’t showing up at work but I was very uncomfortable. And there were some work days where I had to go in late because I felt the nausea was so overwhelming, but but the number of days that that happened was just a handful. Okay. Yeah. I guess that’s what I mean. I felt like it was within reason if I wasn’t debilitated for an extended period of time. I just had some kind of mild morning sickness or morning nausea.

 

paulette  6:49  

Yeah, yeah. I mean, obviously everybody talks about that, and I understand it as a as a common part of pregnancy. Yeah, for me, the felt sense of it was much more kind of dramatic than what I imagined. I guess. It’s hard to imagine what nausea feels like all the time. You know, without going through it, but it’s just a it’s such a powerful reminder that you’re busy. Your body is busy.

 

chelsea  7:13  

Your body is busy. That’s so true. Yeah. Yeah, it’s interesting. I remember I mainly I tend to downplay it in my mind a little bit because I wasn’t throwing up actively for any length of time, but there were a lot of mornings where so my husband and I would we live very close to our office and we’ve walked to work together and there were mornings the smells of the city and the city sidewalk. Really. were overwhelming and I’d have to go very slow because between the nausea and the tiredness, but I remember him kind of leaving me. We didn’t I just couldn’t get to the office of you. Okay.

 

paulette  7:51  

And then the second trimester is smooth. It sounds like

 

chelsea  7:53  

yeah, I remember it being pretty happy and smooth. And you know, the house Hunt was stressful, but particularly as it went along, and I could start to feel the baby. I felt that I felt very, there was a lot of joy in it for both he and I we would read together at night he would read to the baby and it’s just the sweetest moments I would say of of our marriage and our that part of our lives.

 

paulette  8:22  

In the book we talked about how I think your husband attended. Maybe we’re going to be looking at as a boy, yeah. What’s it called? To man, which is Yeah,

 

chelsea  8:32  

it is main placement. So yeah. And so that’s the look, I think that’s like the local group that licenses this program, which is or or buys the license from the National Program, which is called Daddy bootcamp. And it’s offered in hospitals around the state and Yeah, he did that program. It was really amazing. I mean, so So I’m, you know, reading all of the baby books and pregnancy books that I could get my hands on. We took some classes together at the local hospital. And then he goes off to this daddy bootcamp, which is such a great program where they bring in recent dads, so dads with babies, I think under six months old, and and then there’s a facilitator who’s been through the program himself. And there has been curriculum, things that they want to talk about, but there’s also kind of open, open question, question and answer period where they can just interact with these new dads ask them what it’s really like, ask them what’s hard, and also just the dads bring the babies to the class and so there they are feeding them and comforting them with changing their diapers and they can see all of that happen in front of them, where the dads are doing it independently. I think that’s important. Nice,

 

paulette  9:46  

is super cool. I can imagine somewhat transformative to allow you to imagine what you will one day be in the not so distant future.

 

chelsea  9:54  

Yes. And what you can choose to be I think that’s a big part of them. Yeah. That’s a big part of the messaging of the program that you get to choose you get to choose there all these messages about gender roles and and who does what but actually, you can make it up for yourself. You can be as engaged as you want to be. And here’s how and here’s how you can think about it.

 

paulette  10:18  

Yeah, that is awesome. I will definitely put a link to that in the show notes just so people can find it because I read it was like it would have been so great have had we had something like that when we were going through it. And not

 

chelsea  10:29  

only that I sometimes think that there needs to be a version of this for mothers to we have mommy groups that you know, find if you’re lucky to write one fit for you. That’s after the fact. But I’ve heard this as I talked to, as I talk to parents for this book. I mean, one thing I heard from a bunch of mothers was the sense that they did all of the prenatal education and they read the books and they went to the classes but they never had this time to sit and talk about and think about what motherhood was going to mean for them who they were as a person. And I kind of think that’s a little bit of what happens at that boot camp is they actually talk about self actualization, what that will feel like in fatherhood and and I think we need some equivalent in motherhood that I haven’t seen defined yet

 

paulette  11:18  

agree that every birth two things are born a baby and a mother and we focus so much on the baby that you just the mother, you know, you changed roles. And it’s a little bit like being pushed from a cliff because things that matter before and things that you were good at before media don’t necessarily apply to the new job. Right? 

 

chelsea  11:37  

And I’m sure we’ll get into this,

but I think we don’t have that because there’s been this underlying narrative for so long that we aren’t we’re ready we’ve already got what we need to do this job.

 

paulette  11:46  

Yes, I’m tired quotes lined up here. So we’re gonna get to that. 

 

The more I thought about this, the more interested I became in this idea and I went on Facebook and posted about this and found that mommy boot camp does exist now. Boot Camp for dads started in 1990, it was assumed that women had a bunch of resources so no equivalent was ever created. It says this on the website. There are lots of classes that tell her what to expect during labor and delivery. But none of that helped her navigate the changes in her relationship and life. Once she brings this new little human home. Although friends and family can be a valuable resource, nothing replaces the value of sitting down and getting straight answers for women who are just in mom to these shoes and are willing to share what worked best for them and what they learned that will be valuable for expectant moms to know if you’re interested you can check it out in the show notes. 

 

So going into the third trimester, do you have a vision of what you think the birth is going to be like or what you’re hoping for?

 

chelsea  12:44  

Yes, I definitely was in the camp I had. I always get her name wrong because I ina may Gaskin right so I had read Ina May Gaskins famous book about natural childbirth and kind of getting in the right frame of mind for for that experience. And I really wanted to have an unmedicated natural childbirth. I definitely did have a sense that it was okay if that didn’t happen that I was just going to do my best and see and kind of take it as it came but that is definitely what I wanted.

 

paulette  13:22  

Take us to the day. How do you today’s the day…

 

chelsea  13:25  

yeah, well,so that was my goal for sure. And I was in in for one of my regularly scheduled checkups. And I remember very clearly going into my boss’s office saying I have to go to this checkup. I’ll be back in about an hour and a half. And he said Well, you never know because I was so I was so far along. I was 30 approaching 38 weeks, and he was like you never know a good day could be the day and I was like I think I’ll be back because I felt good. I actually remember I had like a very cute maternity dress on I had a long list of things that I needed to do that day and and and I went and my blood pressure was high and and they kept me and monitored it for a little while. There was something else that they monitored you for previously but so anyways, I go in and my blood pressure’s high and and they monitor it for an hour or so. It said no, it’s definitely high. And I can remember the doctor looking at me and saying sort of matter of factly it’s time to move towards an induction and bursting into tears and saying no and of course, it was definitely a high enough where I see now that it was it was the right choice to make and it stayed high, you know through my induction so. So

 

paulette  14:52  

the presence of mind to say that, Oh, this could be preeclampsia or you’re just more focused on the fact that you’re giving birth earlier than you wanted.

 

chelsea  15:00  

I both I think at first I was like how can this be I feel fine. Yeah, and I’m not ready and I don’t want this to be rushed. And then as they monitor it for that extended period and then after as I went into the hospital to prepare for the induction, it became clear to me that it was high and it was staying high and that we needed to do this.

 

paulette  15:23  

Yeah,

 

chelsea  15:24  

so one thing I had been pretty stressed. At the end of my pregnancy we had found a house and we had started kitchen renovation and had moved in the house before the renovation was complete because we had to and also around that same period, we had realized that we had things in the house that hadn’t been properly medicated for and so suddenly I was like oh my God living in this house. And there’s this risk here and is it safe and you know, we had the state inspector come in and and tell us it was safe for us to be there and and there was a lot happening. And so now looking back, it’s no surprise I guess that that’s where I ended up but I definitely felt like on top of all of those stressors to now have a shortened timeline to get ready for the baby and deal with all of that. Yeah, it was it. I was overwhelmed by it for sure. Once we’re in the hospital, I think we did a good job of shifting our frame of mind to just be like, we need to just focus on what’s right here in front of us. The induction took a full three and a half days  so we had some time

 

Paulette: Oh Good lord…

 

Chelsea: so we had some time…I was really lucky to be in a hospital where they don’t rush you through the induction and so they started the induction and with Pitocin, very low dose Pitocin and very quickly. The baby’s heart rate was going up and so stopped the Pitocin and they gave me I forget what it’s called but insertion they give you overnight 

 

Paulette: cervadil? 

 

Chelsea: Yeah, give me cervadil and that started the Pitocin they even lower dose the next morning and I was monitored that whole time which was probably the worst part of it honestly, wearing the monitor for those days and and then fortunately I did progress and slowly at first and then work quickly and the night when I was in labor really the active labor. I don’t think anyone realized that I was as active labor as I was and I don’t think even I realized it because I had this crazy thing happened with both of my pregnancies where I would feel a contraction and it would be intense. And then it would be over and I would immediately fall asleep or pass out not sure which and and then I’d be woken up with another contraction and I just I don’t know I managed that sort of quietly and so I went through a lot of my active labor kind of just sitting in the middle of the night through my bed. 

 

There was a nurse there with me but I suddenly it was very clear that suddenly I needed to push and she thought that I was nowhere, nowhere near ready. And when she checked me. I was right there and I pushed for a very short period of time. And so there was a very interesting moment during the delivery where I got very scared and things felt tense suddenly and I sort of can see the faces on the doctor and the nurse still kind of watching the monitors and I let a contraction go without pushing at all and and they kind of that were like because and I said I feel afraid and and then they were like we’re encouraging me on the next one to go ahead and I pushed and he came out he had the umbilical cord around his neck three times. 

 

Paulette: Wow. 

 

Chelsea: And they cut it. He was fine. But I always I do think back to that moment. What was that? What was this moment of intuition potentially and I knew he needed a break for a second and I needed a break and then we did it we did it or something else do the opposite of that where I don’t know it was just very interesting moment. And so he came out and they put him on my chest and I said He’s so tiny. He was he was five pounds. 12 ounces. And so yeah, that feeling of wonder and joy at having him and real fear of how small and vulnerable he was definitely kind of defined my early weeks as a mother. I think

 

paulette  20:07  

my you know, while you’re telling this story, all I’m thinking is oh my god, you must be so tired by the time you actually comes to pushing because it’s three days of not great sleep. And then and then you know the big marathon is still ahead of you. 

 

Chelsea; Yeah 

 

Paulette: and and you know, people I think can obviously see that breastfeeding is a relationship and is very much dance between mother and child, but that’s probably true of birth too. So it doesn’t, it seems to me, you know, potentially legit that it was intuition and the YouTuber had your way to communicate physically like you have been for the last 40 weeks or Yeah, eight weeks.

 

chelsea  20:47  

Yeah, yeah, I think that’s right. I mean I am. The nurse came up to me afterward and said something like, you know, if you have any more children, I think it’s gonna go well for you you have you she said something along the lines of You have you have a very strong like intuition for your body and I and I, I was in the middle of it all didn’t really get to ask her what she meant about that. But I have wondered and I wondered specifically about that moment of what were they seeing on the monitors and it wouldn’t have confirmed my fear in that moment. And, and or I don’t know I don’t it. Yeah.

 

paulette  21:29  

I mean, it’s interesting because you feel fear, but you don’t have the words to describe exactly what it is. That feels like intuition

 

chelsea  21:34  

Yes. That feels from Yeah, yeah. But yeah, and then and then he was there and he you know, he was so tiny. I mean, that’s a wide I had lots of hair and and and he was he was just so tiny. I can

 

paulette  21:56  

only see from the neck up but you don’t seem like a giant person. So when they say he was underweight or no, don’t even be bigger.

 

chelsea  22:03  

No, he they didn’t. I thought it would be bigger. They had told me that he was going to be bigger. Also he was measuring, you know fetal measurements were or I can’t remember where they put it, but it was more of an average weight. And you know, he wasn’t what’s the phrase when when a baby’s underweight, low birth weight. He wasn’t technically low birth weight, but he was kind of close to that. And then we struggled in those first days to just start initiating breastfeeding. He had some trouble suckling, we had to help him learn how to do that. And my milk didn’t come in right away. And so that amplified that feeling, okay, that’s all he is and how he really didn’t have much weight to lose. Yeah, it’s early days

 

paulette  22:44  

in your research. Did you come across the fact that potentially an induction at 38 weeks is highly correlated with a bigger window before milk production comes in because the symphony of hormones that’s supposed to create that is not really being created?

 

chelsea  23:03  

I know that birth experiences can shape your milk how it comes in for sure. I don’t I don’t have this specific research to cite for you. But I know that that is generally true that and and more true, I think if you have a C section, but but it can be true, definitely with induction as well, I think

 

paulette  23:20  

so the short answer to this question is yes, C section can delay milk production, and so too can induction because of the potential for added interventions, which is not to say that it happens all the time, but that it does happen often enough that if it happens to you know that you’re not alone. There are more details on this topic in the show notes 

 

Paulette: and how was postpartum for the first one.

 

chelsea  23:44  

I mean, so that was what prompted me to write this. This book really so my, my gosh, how was postpartum with the first one? So it was okay. I think I had unreasonably high expectations for myself in that time.

 

paulette  24:06  

So what what time What did you expect?

 

chelsea  24:10  

I expected you know, loss of sleep and for things to be hard and, and that I would need some help. And certainly that I was bad. I was going to have 12 weeks off and I was glad for that. I did not expect a change in my mental states that went beyond sleep loss. I had I think I had a sense of postpartum depression as you know, as I write in the book that it was sort of like the flu you either had it or if you didn’t have it, then you were kind of stable and steady. I didn’t have a clear sense of the real transformation that happens in that period for all new parents whether they experienced any symptoms of anxiety or depression or not. And, and then the reality of my time was that I felt really obsessive about my son’s safety and well being and about my ability to take care of him and, and so I didn’t feel you know, certainly this was eight years ago, the symptom checklist for postpartum depression was more of like feeling withdrawn or cold or unemotional, and I felt the opposite of that I felt extremely engaged with him and and worried and like I couldn’t look away and also really concerned about the safety of the world around us our food and the air in our neighborhood and house and how was I going to keep them safe when it was hard to control all of these factors that that affected our our safety. And so I felt really worried and then I also felt quite worried about the worry itself. I felt like it was this this sense of overwhelm kind of drowning out the love or the warmth that I wanted to be expressing towards him and and was it you know, a sign of something that may be broken or missing in me if I didn’t if I couldn’t just focus on that love and that forms then what did it mean about me as as a mother?

 

paulette  26:18  

Oh, so I’m very sorry that you had this extremely stressful first step into parenthood because that sounds really stressful and it is vigilance is, you know, is energy costly, right? Just it’s exhausting. It’s right. It’s a really hard way to live. And this brings us very much into your book. So I have identified three main takeaways I could have identified 30 main takeaways. But so my three takeaways and you should amend these if this is not what you’re thinking is 

  • everything you think that makes a good mother and what makes a bad mother, a good mother shapes your child and what you should be feeling is essentially wrong. That’s number one. 
  • Number two is both chemistry and experience, rewire the brains of all caretakers. Mothers and fathers. And those effects are long lasting. 
  • And the third one is, there are many stories of gendered expectation that women are natural caregivers based on quote unquote science, but the science is done by people with gender expectation. So the scientific findings tend to reflect what the scientists bring to it. And so we can, you can add more to that if you’d like. 
  •  

But going back to the first one, so I wanted to mention three, one you just mentioned was postpartum and was blown away by the fact that the first drug for postpartum depression was what was just approved

 

chelsea  27:39  

yesterday, and it’s still pretty much inaccessible to most sorry, how long

 

paulette  27:43  

have you been been giving birth for? Right get the clock out, right. So that’s not but that’s one of them. And then I wrote down the three more that I was really that I thought were really profound. So one of them was golden hour. And he talked about this podcast conversation between Hillary Frank and innovate Gaskin, the author of the natural birthing Bible, and you tell the story about how Hillary Frank says the birth didn’t go the way that she envisioned it. She was empowered like you were by you may ask and and that’s not however has been shipped epidural ship Pitocin she had been Peasy on all these things that contradicts kind of the vision she had built herself. And she walked away feeling like a failure. And kudos to ina may Gaskin for, for revising how she talked about those things because she was saying, in particular, that people have come to think of the golden hour as something that if it’s missed, then you’re not going to bond properly with your baby. And she says that’s absolutely not true. Another thing you talk about is oxytocin as the love drug, which everybody thinks of it in that way, but basically what you say is hormones are fantastically complicated, and work in a symphony and not a solo. That’s right. And they do many things and men also have changes in their oxytocin and testosterone and progesterone and all this stuff. So it’s much more complicated than that story we’ve been sold. Yeah. And because a woman’s body was made through production we all should be able to do it, if not naturally at least bad. That’s like an idea. We walk in with what was the maternal mortality rate before we had medical interventions was super high, right?

 

chelsea  29:17  

I don’t know for sure. But my my assumption is a couple of things. One, I think like the real the real depends on which point in history you’re talking about, I guess, but back Oh, kind of pre Industrial Revolution. Anyways, I think that death was just honestly a much more common part of society. And so I mean, many more kids died, people died younger and people saw you know, other women die or be injured in childbirth. Often that was part of life. So maybe it was just so woven into the experience that it was and and it was the God given role to write. So sort of take what comes

 

paulette  29:57  

I’m going to end my conversation. With Chelsea here. I’m grateful to her both for candidly sharing her personal story of stepping into motherhood, and for her book that helps us all step into this giant transformation, with more awareness of both what’s to come. Some of the amazing undoubted benefits of this journey, both for burning people and our partners. Really interesting really speaks to the rest of my conversation

 

Episode 97SN: Her Birth & Postpartum inspired her to find a better way to Postpartum: Kaitlin’s Story, Part I

We–ALL of US (in the US)–are doing Postpartum wrong. Once we experience it with our first born, we learn this, and all make plans to do something different the second time, if there is a second time. Today’s guest wants to change Postpartum for all of us.

In today’s episode, my guest shares the birth and postpartum experience that propelled her out of her work as a special ed teacher in New York City and into the field of birth workers. Unfortunately, the overwhelming two that she experienced and talks about is likely to sound very familiar. I had my kids 10 years before she did and she could have been describing my postpartum in lots of ways. But what’s new is what she did with that experience, and what she’s doing for birthing people now.

Check out Kaitlin’s company, BeHerVillage

Audio Transcript

Kaitlin McGreyes  0:02  

I poured all my time and energy into the nursery, all the things for the baby. And I neglected to mine with any kind of support for myself. And I blamed myself for it. It didn’t, I thought, wow, I really failed here. You know, I didn’t I didn’t know how hard this was gonna be I obviously did something wrong. And then I became a doula soon after my second birth, and I started seeing that almost all of them had that experience that universal moment of being postpartum, whether it’s three hours postpartum, or it’s a day postpartum or it’s a week postpartum, they all find themselves alone.

Paulette  0:38  

Welcome towards stories from the womb. This is a show that shares true experiences of getting pregnant, being pregnant and giving birth to help shift the common cultural narrative away from the glossy depictions of this enormous transition. You find on all kinds of media to more realistic one. It also celebrates the incredible resilience and strength it takes to create another person and release that new person from your body into the world. I’m your host, Paulette Kamenecka. I’m a writer and an economist and a mother of two girls. And boy that I struggle with this transition.

In today’s episode, my guest shares the birth and postpartum experience that propelled her out of her work as a special ed teacher in New York City and into the field of birth workers. Unfortunately, the overwhelming two that she experienced and talks about is likely to sound very familiar. I had my kids 10 years before she did and she could have been describing my postpartum in lots of ways. But what’s new is what she did with that experience, and what she’s doing for birthing people. Now. This is a really inspiring story. So let’s get to it. 

Today. We have something unusual, I almost never promote a business because I don’t want to sell anything but but today is different because I heard about this miraculous woman on podcast who wants us all to reimagine one of the fundamental, almost rites of passage for a pregnant woman in America. The baby shower. Basically, I heard about her company for women in postpartum. I thought this is genius. And we should all be doing this. And so I’m so excited to introduce Kaitlin McGreyes. I say your name right. Humans got

 

Kaitlin  2:21  

it so close. It’s McGreyes. Okay. My husband and I combined her last name. So it’s actually graph and Reyes but together.

 

Paulette  2:29  

I love it. Okay. So Caitlin, McGreyes. Thank you so much for coming on the show. I’m so excited to hear your personal story and the story of the company. I’m excited to hear it all. So will you tell us where you’re from?

 

Kaitlin  2:42  

And a little bit about yourself? Absolutely. Thank you so much, Paulette. That’s awesome. I am Kaitlin McGreyes. I have three children, seven, eight and 10. I’m from Long Island, New York. And I am a doula turned founder of beer village because essentially I was a special ed teacher. I went through the motherhood experience, the very typical American motherhood experience. And I felt like many of us, underwhelmed to traumatize spectrum depends on the day. And I realized that that was sort of like a universal experience. To enter motherhood, alone, unsupported. And I had this one moment where I sat in my nursery three days postpartum. And I was trying to figure out how to breastfeed trying to figure out which way was up trying to figure out how to take care of this post C section body. My husband was already back at work. Oh my god. I know he didn’t get any time off for that one. So I gave birth Saturday morning at 520. And he was back at work while I’m still in the hospital. And he worked for New York City. It just they didn’t have pay leave then we couldn’t afford unpaid leave. It was a whole thing. So I had a very bumpy entry into motherhood. And I just remember sort of looking around at my apartment and seeing all the beautiful gifts, my perfect nursery, it’s where I it’s where I poured all my time and energy into nursery all the things for the baby. And I neglected to line up any kind of support for myself, and I blamed myself for it. It didn’t I thought wow, I really failed here. You know, I didn’t I didn’t know how hard this was gonna be. I obviously did something wrong. And then I became a doula soon after my second birth, and I started supporting hundreds of women over the course of my Doula career, and I started seeing that almost all of them had that experience that universal moment of being postpartum whether it’s three hours postpartum, or it’s a day postpartum or it’s a week postpartum, they all find themselves alone, and without the care that they need, while they’re trying to care for their babies. And all of us are surrounded by stuff. We have the best strollers and the best baby bottles and bouncers and gadgets and devices and our communities. Our loved one spent 1000s of dollars on us at our baby shower to the tune of $12 billion a year on being crazy. And I thought, man, there’s got to be a better way. To do this. This just feel like we’re not doing this right we’ve got this we’ve have moms totally overloaded with stuff for their kids for their babies, and no support totally left alone. And then you have you know, all all this money getting spent on stuff when when there could be a way to spend that on supporting them and what what is the way that we solve this problem? How do we get these funds that are so generously being spent to be spent on hearing for the actual mother? I started thinking about how do we actually go buy a baby shower gift? You know, like how does that happen? We got a baby shower invite usually have some registry information you go you click a few things and and it’s done. It’s sort of just like a task that you do. And what if we shifted the baby shower registry? What if we created a place where instead of all the stuff for babies we could shower the mother with support? What if we could buy her a doula What if we could get her postpartum here but if we get our pelvic floor therapy or lactation visits or mom you need groups or you know meals and laundry and just the whole the things to sort of like envelop this new family in the care they need, which is so impactful. So I pray to be her village.

 

Paulette  6:20  

I was so excited to get into that. I want to hear your story first. And then we’re gonna save time at the end to walk people through what it looks like. What you’re doing now what you’ve learned from doing it, however long you’ve been doing it because it’s such a good idea and when I read that billions of dollars are spent on baby stuff. I thought a that’s crazy and B I totally understand it. Right. It’s that is what we’re geared toward in a way that completely overlooks the mother who’s entirely critical of the baby, right, or health or Well, being her mental state is so fundamentally important. And we’re like, Ah, here’s a rocker, you know, the mean, and the rocker is beautiful, but when you’re sitting alone, crying while you’re breastfeeding, you know, I’m not sure anything about the rocker.

 

Kaitlin  7:10  

That’s exactly I mean that that is my story. My story is that.

 

Paulette  7:14  

So let’s start off slow here. So do you have siblings in your family? Did you come from a big family?

 

Unknown Speaker  7:19  

I have one older brother.

 

Paulette  7:22  

So when you were younger, did you think I’m going to have a family or did that affect your idea about family?

 

Kaitlin  7:28  

I think I always knew I wanted children. It’s kind of funny. This is like a funny thing to say, Well, I I knew I wanted children and never necessarily wanted to be married. And maybe when I was a 90s kid with divorced parents, so the idea of being stuck in an unhappy marriage was my idea of hell, but I knew I wanted to help kids. I was always very maternal. I was always playing house. I always was loved to take care of my little cousins when they were babies. But I didn’t necessarily imagine that happening with a partner. I just knew I kind of assumed I would live on my own and then do IVF or something. And then I was a special ed teacher in New York City. And the Para, which is like a teacher’s assistant, in the classroom next door. He was really really cute. He was really, really cute. And I thought to myself, he’s so cute, and honestly, he was more than cute. He was hot. But I thought man, he can’t be nice. He’s probably kind of you know, his personality probably is terrible because he’s so good looking. And then I went up and I talked to him. And he told me that when he’s not working with the special needs kids in our school that he’s he works at a puppy daycare. Oh man. He’s everything you know. So I feel very, very, very hard for him. And I ended up marrying him and I just remember this overwhelming feeling of wow, I just want to make humans with you. It was the most was maybe the first step in the primal nature. of motherhood, you know, because on paper, having kids didn’t really make sense. It’s still quite, it doesn’t make that much sense to have kids on paper. It’s expensive, takes a lot of your energy the extra time it shifts your whole life. But there’s this space in my body. You know, this like gut space that just has this urge to have children and to have children with him. So So yeah, so that’s what we do. I’m very quickly went from a single living on my own in the city, going out all the time to living with my partner married and then got pregnant two months after we got married. Wow. So yeah, and then had three kids in less than four years. So when I do things, Paulette, I do them big.

 

Paulette  9:41  

For the sake of be her village, I’m excited to hear that. I’m glad. So it sounds like it was easy to get pregnant.

 

Kaitlin  9:48  

It was scarily easy for you know, it’s like it can go either way. Right. It can be like wow, this is really hard and heart wrenching. But it can also be like, Wow, we just think about getting pregnant. And we all three times it was incredibly, incredibly easy.

 

Paulette  10:01  

Yeah. Okay, so for the first one, did you walk into pregnancy with an idea of what it would be like?

 

Kaitlin  10:08  

No, I was the first person in my social circle. I was only 27 which in New York City is very young to start having kids. I feel like the people I know don’t start think about until they’re like 33 And they’re like, start considering it. So at 27 I was the first person I knew and was already in my circle to have a baby so I had almost no expectation and I don’t know I have this expectation that everything would be really easy. I also I also have this invincibility this like 27 year old invincibility like nothing can hurt me because I you know, tell I know how to tell people to go at themselves. You to like and that will save me which in many situations. Like it wasn’t enough. I remember watching the business of being born. And before I had my first baby and thinking, Oh, I can handle that. You know, I was horrified at what I saw. And I thought I can handle that.

 

Paulette  11:06  

Was it was it? Was it a vaginal deliveries they showed?

 

Kaitlin  11:10  

Well, what they showed on us as being born is a plant homebirth different C section because the baby was breech so she was like eight centimeters and they had to transfer pretty quickly but they they walk you through the cascade of interventions, you know, mostly in the epidural, the stall, the C section, that sort of thing. And, and I just sort of felt immune, I felt like I could handle all of that. So

 

Paulette  11:34  

how do we know today’s the day or you know, the baby’s gonna be born?

 

Kaitlin  11:38  

Because the midwife told me it’s time to go to the hospital and get the baby out.

 

Paulette  11:43  

So you do wake up with contractions and you know their contractions

 

Kaitlin  11:47  

know the midwives. Were working at a birth center in New York. There was only one so I won’t name it but you guys can figure it out. They were working at a birth center and sort of saying, Hey, this is midwifery care. But the rules at the time in New York State did not allow midwives to own birth center. So they were actually puppets for an OB run and owned facility. So I went for 41 weeks screaming Wow. And the midwife just said, Okay, it’s time there wasn’t a discussion. It wasn’t true midwifery care. And I’m always sort of careful to say that it was not true midwifery care. They were just a puppet for OB care. And it was a little bit of a bait and switch. And it’s it’s unfortunate because I tried, you know, like I tried to line up and out of hospital birth they tried lining up a midwifery led team, but it’s it made to him. I didn’t like, deep enough, but I think part of that experience was that I was a little idealistic. I was a little bit like my just gonna be my you know like I’m part of I think my deep skepticism the unfolding this as I’m saying it but like, what am I deep skepticism about the existing systems and and how they serve us is due to this like I did all the right things. I checked all the boxes, you know, I planted out of hospital birth I got a midwifery team. I took the childbirth class, I prepared as best as I could. And still, the system just took me in and systematically shut me down, took away choices took away my voice.

 

Paulette  13:25  

So before we get to the hospital, how did you come to the conclusion that you wanted an out of hospital birth? What What made you make that choice?

 

Kaitlin  13:33  

That’s a great question. I don’t really know my mom had a vaginal delivery with me and my brother, and my brother and I and my 10 year old would be correcting me and my grandma was my brother and I, I think I was just it was the beginning. Of when I start considering another human being like my son. I think it was just the beginning of this, like, what could be the best for him and what I was reading was the best is less intervention, the you know, the business would be important. It’s like how do we avoid this cycle? How do we avoid I was just sort of curious that I guess I got led down that path of looking for an alternative and I’m not somebody that has ever wanted to walk the mainstream path. Like part of my personality, so I think it makes perfect sense that I was that I was exploring my options. I’m also somebody that is very intellectual. I like to know as much information as I can it helps reduce my anxiety. So I think just in doing the, the research and looking and going and meeting people and finding out what is the best way to have this baby. That was what led me down this path and I got so close, like some key things that were sort of outside of my control. For you know, that’s that’s where everything sort of went sideways.

 

Paulette  14:52  

So you went to the midwives just for a regular checkup. Was that your intention?

 

Kaitlin  14:56  

I went to the sonogram place for a 41 week sonogram to check on, I guess, you know, just the like normal, non stress test and water levels and whatnot. And it was the hottest day of July, you know, and I was my water was a little low. And I didn’t know I didn’t have a doula. It’s a big part of it. I didn’t have a doula. I thought that a doula would make the experience less intimate. I thought a doula was unnecessary because I thought my midwives had my back. I didn’t understand like the power dynamic that the midwives were working for OBS and I didn’t understand that even if they aren’t working for OBS that they’re trying to exist and give care in a system where they are liable in a system where they need to be covered by insurance in a system where they have to maintain hospital privileges. I had no idea about the complexities of that. So I felt that my midwife would protect me rather than be one of the people that sort of a mouthpiece for the larger system. And so, so I was told my water was low. And I remember standing on the street in Brooklyn, and she called me and said, It’s time to get the baby out. Go to the hospital. Not a question, not an informative conversation just it has been deemed it has been decided. And I remember bursting into tears to figure out why the tears you know, in the moment it’s almost like my body knew how wrong this all felt, but I couldn’t you know, when you’re in that sort of panic stress, you can’t pinpoint it. Years later, and many, many hours of contemplation, but I think I just went into immediate trust mode and I don’t know that I could have figured out well, yeah, because maybe, maybe I wanted to have a voice in my care. Maybe I wanted to be a decision maker instead of a passive participant maybe being told what was going to happen. Didn’t feel good for me and maybe I needed trauma informed care you know, it’s such a subtle thing, but it’s a huge thing. If she had said, Hey, this is what’s going on. And these are our options. Yeah, take an hour, go to lunch, go connect, go get in a room with your husband. I was by myself. Go get in a room with your husband haven’t take you out to lunch and discuss the options you know, just something as simple as that there was nothing urgent about me. You know, my water was a little low. Okay, baby was fine. So something like that would have just completely shifted the experience and and I think that’s where when I eventually become a doula and do all of this work those moments stick with me. It’s not it’s not about how the baby comes out. It really isn’t. It’s not about what medical things happen. It’s about having the space and room to adjust. It’s about having people speak to you respectfully. It’s about having a team that maintains your power your autonomy, your centering in the entire experience. It’s just that birth from that phone call on I was I was just an annoyance to everybody. I was just the thing they had to deal with. And that’s how I felt I felt disempowered and voiceless and powerless. And it I mean, it continues to grow. At first that was the best part of the birth leader was that

 

Paulette  18:05  

this is this is something I hear often from women and the fundamental question is Were things done for you or to you? Oh, they were done to me. Right because you had no choice but that’s that seems to be what it turns on. You know how much control you have. So you’re crying in the street. What happens next you call your husband.

 

Kaitlin  18:25  

I call my husband and I call my mom and they meet me at the hospital or my mom like picks up my husband and I don’t remember exactly we all meet at the hospital. And, and the midwife needs to be in triage. And so the thing to know about this situation, too, is that this birthing center was always in flux. I don’t know the workings behind the scene, but I know as a patient and then as a doula when I would have patients there. They they’re just sort of constantly in flux. So at the time, they had privileges at mammography. So I went to my mother’s hospital in Brooklyn, which was incredibly far away from my home and my parents home. We were trying to have birth center birth and that this was plan B. But the other thing that had happened is that there was this like shifting of all the midwives on the staff, and only one or two of them had like five or six had privileges at the hospital. The sense I got from the midwife who’s now a home birth midwife in Brooklyn, was that she was exhausted. And didn’t want to be there. And I got the overwhelming sense she wasn’t happy in the position she was in which is fine but it definitely bled into my care you know, she dropped me off in triage. I got an IV in my hand. I remember hating the IV so much. And then now get this pull that you’re gonna die. I was set up for a Cytotec induction in the C section. recovery room. Yep. So I was lying there, eating a sandwich. Not allowed to get up. I didn’t know you know, this is like this is like another me not allowed to get up not allowed to move. Getting double doses of side attack because the first couple didn’t work. Surrounded by semi conscious moaning women. Oh my God, who had just come back from a C section or waking up from anesthesia. Whatever it was like it’s surgical recovery room on the OB floor. And the midwife who I’m sure is overworked. His that she’s the only one you know, that has hospital privileges. It just, she was in her own place. She’s like, okay, by all means Call me if you feel like you need an epidural. That’s not midwifery care. By the way. For anyone who’s listening. That’s not midwifery care I was getting. I was getting OB care through the mouth of a midwife. Call me feeling an epidural. Call me if you feel like you need an epidural. It’s actually what she said. Cool.

 

Paulette  20:56  

Thanks. So I got it from here. Thanks. Anyway.

 

Kaitlin  21:00  

Thank you so much, you You’re the worst. So I Yeah, so I the the Cytotec kicked in around 11pm

 

Paulette  21:08  

Is that Pitocin so it was it was like Is it attack is a cervical ripening

 

Kaitlin  21:13  

or it’s an off label use. So it there’s a lot of controversy oversight attack. It has its uses. I’m not this is not an anti Cytotec podcast. It’s just that was what I had, but incredibly effective. It’s also it’s the abortion drug, it causes intense uterine contraction. Oh, so it’s an off label use there’s something like it’s for ulcers. It’s an ulcer medication that the OB is used to induce and also to control bleeding and also to I believe it’s the abortion. I don’t know though.

 

Paulette  21:45  

Just a quick note, here, Caitlyn is right. According to medical websites, Cytotec aka visa protocol, not sure if I’m pronouncing that correctly, is also a drug that’s used off label by OBS for various things including inducing abortion. It’s one of the two medications used in the abortion pill. There are links in the show notes if you’re interested in details.

 

Kaitlin  22:07  

So I get that it’s incredibly effective. I started having essentially transition level contractions every three minutes deep, deep, deep contractions, and it is almost unbearable because the nurse Wendy is now in this surgical recovery room. She’s taking care of 20 women and me who’s laboring and she won’t let me quote unquote, let me because I didn’t know I didn’t. She wasn’t allowed to not let me write. Wouldn’t let me get up she kept saying well, I have superior commanders. She would make me live not even just lay but lay flat on my back. I had those the things that go on your legs. Like clap preventative thing. I had blood pressure cuff. I had the flippy thing on your hand, but I was essentially strapped down. Even though technically not shackles really felt like it. And I remember just she was forcing me to lay the waves were so intense and so fast. And I remember saying I need an epidural I started vomiting. I started shaking uncontrollably, which is all now like now I know it’s all part of like I was dilating I was now I know I’ve actually been incredibly fast labor my body. So the baby when it’s ready, so good to know, but my body took to the induction, I think a lot faster than anybody expected it to. And I remember asking her if I can get out to the bathroom and she said to me, Well, no, you really look like you’re in charge. I can’t let you get up and she made me use a bedpan How humiliating how dehumanizing. I was conscious. I was not an epidural. There was no reason I should not have been allowed to get up out of that bed. I shouldn’t walk to school. There’s a lot of shoulds in the story, but it’s part of why I’m so passionate about everybody getting to let says this is the foundation of my work right now. It is this. I was like a trapped animal and not in a good way. I was like an animal, my spiritual unmedicated me back to you, but like a wonderful, primal, beautiful goddess animal. This was like being in a cage and I remember I was I was throwing up I was shaking. She was trapping me and honestly, I don’t know how much time I gave birth to 5:20am Voc section. This started at 11 I don’t think that much time has really time doesn’t exist in labor. You know, it felt like 10 years to me. And I remember my husband and I had prepared with childbirth classes and it’s his role right to kind of support me and not wanting to throw. My mother and him weren’t allowed to touch me unless they had cold rags because I was so hot and I couldn’t take the touch. They were like deer in headlights. If there’s ever a reason to have a doula it was just the look of their faces. The eyes not knowing what to do with me. And I remember saying out loud, I want an epidural. And he looked at me and he was like, really, you know, and I feel for him because he does his job. Right. And we think it’s our job to talk people out of epidurals. It is not our job to help people. It really isn’t is our job to offer other alternatives. But epidural always has to be on the table. We need to listen to women and I’m so adamant about that because because he listened to me in that moment. And I needed him to listen to me because he was like, Are you sure? And I looked at him and I said, not like this. This is not it’s so far gone. You know, I talked about going down an epidural. I was talking about like, you know, with a flower crown and a birth center or anything. Like obviously, I just imagined it being so much more wholesome and holistic and centered and I was able, you can’t say no epidural and then take away every other tool they have to cope. Suffering. And so he understood that and the funniest thing happened. Well, it’s not really funny. I said to her swinging, I said to like an epidural. And she said the strangest thing. She goes, Are you sure you want an epidural? That means you’d have to go into a labor and delivery room. And I was like, What do you mean I could get my own? Okay, yeah, no, I want that. Like no, I want it more. What do you think is the weirdest weirdest thing so the residents run and check me because I spent so much time as a doula talking people through the conversation about getting examined and what what pads do go on and this and that, and we really slow down the labor around these points, the cervical exams being a big, big one. And I remember it was just like, checkmate, whatever. I’m just I mean, after all, I don’t care if you check me or not, but I was checked and in retrospect, I was four to five centimeters and that was like two hours or so after. Wow. Look, I was rocking and there was a reason why I was in so much discomfort. So they gave me the epidural or they hold on to the head. So they get me over to l&d. And the l&d nurse is worse than Monday. She was so just didn’t want me to be there. She didn’t like me. She hated her job. You can just tell when people hate them. And I think too, as a birthing person or a birthing moment you press especially sensitive to energy because you have to see who’s a danger to you. So I think I’m already pretty sensitive to people’s energy. But I was really quite sensitive that night. So I remember going into the bathroom and wiping and there was blood, mucus and blood like I was opening really beautifully. And I remember sitting on the toilet. This is right before I’m gonna get my epidural. I remember sitting on the toilet and thinking I could do this What am I doing? But it’s because I was sitting on the toilet I was right. I was able to sort of release it was a completely different experience to sit on the toilet and labor versus being strapped to the bed and labor go figure go figure that was different. So I didn’t know that at this point. You know, I mean, really, I just needed a way out of the school scenario. Everyone was so awful there and I’m getting a C section that I had that this ended it was not the worst part. The C section was the way out of being surrounded by I’m so vulnerable to people who were disrespectful and who couldn’t care less about me. So I get back in my my one fear actually, you know, you asked me that question before about why I went and will say and I just remember the answer, because my biggest fear about birth was not giving birth. It was about getting a needle in my spine. So I was trying to avoid an epidural. And and my fears were founded because this anesthesiologist was female anesthesiologist came in and she gave me the epidural and I remember feeling the needle go into my spine, and it was uncomfortable. It hurt. It was like getting a needle in your spine.

  

I remember being moved and I think I remember being like, oh and I moved and I screamed and she was so

 

Kaitlin    

I don’t know the word for it but but this day and she was like, is it pain or is it just couldn’t believe I was reacting like that and I was like it’s even in getting the relief. I couldn’t get relief from the from the game so awful and looking back at it wasn’t even one of those patients. You know, the one we all fear being the one that like to be honest, I wasn’t even that I was so docile, but I think the morale at that place was really rough. So I got there. And I finally got released and it did its trick, which is great because it doesn’t always work that way for people. So it did have that full relief. But then I was resting as close my eyes and every time I opened my eyes, everybody was still in the room and everybody had really big eyes and my mum looked terrified. And I realized that they were worried about the heartbeat of the baby, that they were watching midwife the midwife had returned. She helped me through the epidural. And you know, it was the worst part about that is that she was actually incredibly comforting. She was very good during the epidural and it would have been a different labor if she stayed if she had to work. I deserved a midwife and I said, So I realized that they were concerned about it and I, I opened my eyes and I looked at midwife and I said, what’s going on? And she said, well, so my baby was going to tack a cardiac instead of radical artic. So the biggest party wasn’t going along. It was actually going to really high up. Which after taking care of strangers, newborn resuscitation protocol, that’s just as dangerous. That’s just as bad of an indication. So there was a heart rate issue. And in retrospect, what happened is essentially his head was a little asymptotic. It was just like a little off. I think it would be opening so quickly, and then the epidural, I’m sure opening me. I think he just got jammed in and stuff. And he just struggled a little bit. So I remember looking at the midwife, and she said I still hate him. We would she said they were all clearly worried about it. They were describing something that was scary. And she said I’m gonna call them the OB and the OB will come in at about 45 minutes. Oh my god. And I want to just like preface this by I said this about me and I would never say this to a pregnant person. I said, Okay, I just want to help the baby. Just get me healthy baby. And I say that because it’s incredibly toxic to say at least the unhealthy baby enters a healthy now that’s not true. I matter. But at that moment, everything I had desired about this birth was so far out of the window, right? What I meant if I had the capacity to speak in a full thought, What I meant is you’ve ruined all of this right? This has already been destroyed. I need to help the baby at the end of this.

 

Paulette  7:30  

I’m going to end my conversation with Caitlin here for today. I so appreciate her sharing her experience of the postpartum period, which I think is regrettably common. Many of us leave the hospital or birthing center to return home are met by our new job that requires work around the clock or that we often do alone and work that we do when we’re exhausted at a time work.

 

Next Friday I will share the rest of this inspiring story.

Episode 95SN: Identity Shift without Identity Crisis in Motherhood: Anne’s Story, Part I

When your interests are shifted to the back seat to make room for the baby’s, you WILL have feelings about it, but most of us never talk about it because it doesn’t fit our idea of motherhood.

Today we discuss some of these challenges, and ways of making sense of them.  I talk to a writer who is also a mother of three about the ideas she brought with her into this giant transition and how she works to balance her family life and work life; the difficulty of this balancing act and the feelings it brought up for her.  I also talk with a fantastic therapist who specializes in helping mothers feel comfortable in motherhood by giving us valuable ways to think about and reframe what may be uncomfortable and conflicting feelings–like love and connection with the baby, but also moments of anger or regret– as we all navigate the job of parenting. what follows is the first part of my conversation with both women.

To find Anne Zimmerman’s work (An Extravagant Hunger: The Passionate Years of M.F.K. Fisher, Love In A Dishand Other Culinary Delights and M.F.K. Fisher: Musings on Wine & Other Libations, check out her website. Here is her writing on related topics.

You can find Jessica Sourci, from Family Tree Wellness here

Audio Transcript

P:

Welcome to War Stories from the Womb.This is a show that shares true experiences of getting pregnant being pregnant and giving birth to help shift the common cultural narrative away from the glossy depictions of this enormous transition you can find on all kinds of media, to a more realistic one.  It also celebrates the incredible resilience and strength it takes to create another person and release that new person from your body into the world. I’m your host, Paulette Kamenecka. I’m a writer and an economist and the mother of two girls and boy did I struggle with this transition….

Today we discuss conflicting feelings about motherhood. i talk to a mother of three about the ideas she brought with her into this giant transition and how she works to balance her family life and work life and I also talk with a fantastic therapist who specializes in helping mothers feel comfortable in motherhood by giving us valuable ways to think about and reframe what me may see as conflicting feelings–like love and connection with irritation and anger– as we all navigate the important job of parenting. what follows is the first part of my conversation with both women.

Paulette  0:03  

Hi  thanks so much for coming on the show. Can you introduce yourself and tell us where you’re from?

Anne  0:07  

My name is Anne Zimmerman, and I am a writer and mother living in Portland, Oregon.

Paulette  0:15  

Anne it’s so lovely to have you on. I should confess that you were my writing teacher at Stanford for a classified suck and you’re a beautiful, beautiful writer. And that was a great class. So I’m excited to have him on. So one thing that’s interesting about your story is you have three kids. You are not Mormon but you grew up in Salt Lake City, which I think of as a pretty happy place and a place filled with big families. So maybe correct me if I’m wrong. Is that your experience?

Anne  0:44  

Yeah, you’re right. And it’s interesting because I’ve gone through various periods in my life where I think about the Mormon Church and the influence of the Mormon Church and the influence of the psychology of the Mormon church a lot because it is really interesting. Parents are not from Utah. And my family has not never been Mormon, but I was born in Salt Lake City. I lived there until I was 18. And my parents are still there. So I continue to go back there fairly frequently. And so it is baked into who I am in it. For those that have been to Salt Lake. You will know that it’s laid out on a grid with the Mormon temple at the center all the street names are keyed off of the Mormon, Mormon temple in the center of the city. So I grew up in a in a beautiful old grid neighborhood and of the like 18 houses on either side of the street. At the time, there were maybe only three other families that were not Mormon. I mean, maybe an older couple or two who did not have children. But in terms of the kids I grew up with, and there were a lot of them. There were at one point there was a family across the street had eight. There were you know, big families and the Mormon church was just pervasive, and I knew it, because I always knew that we weren’t Mormon. It was very clear. We were not going to go to the Mormon church. We were not going to go to the Mormon church just to see what was happening or try it out or anything like that. But it wasn’t until I got a lot older that I was like, oh, so what what was that like, you know, most if not all of the women at home, I should pause and say I only have one brother who’s five years younger than I am. So I did sort of experience something different within my own family unit, but just in terms of being out in the neighborhood or playing with other people from school. Or just being at school, this culture of child after child after child and also everything just seeming really I mean, you’re right. It’s like it doesn’t describe it but perfect and happy is is really true. I think you see it now in social media. I used to have a more than obsession with following in sort of humans, the lives of Mormon and mommy bloggers back when blogging was more of a thing or Instagram because it is in a way it is something that’s so familiar and comfortable to me. Yeah, just that whole we’re gonna have a baby and then we’re gonna have another baby and everything’s gonna be happy and everything is gonna be perfect and everybody’s gonna match. And we’re gonna make cookies and dad comes home and we play basketball and you know, just this very wholesome, very happy, very clean, white, obviously, culture and just I don’t know, just even talking about it. There is still something that is like, appealing about that, even though now being a mother. I sort of see that there that there’s, you know, dark dirty corners. There have to be there.

Paulette  3:48  

Yeah, having kids is too complicated to have just one

Anne  3:52  

more than I mean. We do have three children. And when I went into my motherhood experience, I think I thought we would only have two and we wanted a third child, we plan to have a third child, but that adds to the chaos factor. And sometimes when I’m in just very normal, but chaotic moments at home, I’m like, wow, so then what’s it like if you get each kid to their lesson, that’s their passion that they are willing to live or die for, you know, three tantrums or whatever it just it’s work. It’s it’s an incredible amount of patience and management. And chaos

Paulette  4:28  

yeah, it’s certainly it’s harder than a lot, right? parenting has very good marketing has we all go into it thinking it’s not going to be quite as hard as it is? 

Anne: Right? 

P: We focus on that on the easy, lovely parts that everyone wants to share and glorify and there’s you know, reasons to do that. But it is an incomplete picture. So it sounds like you grew up thinking you were gonna have a family. 

A: Yes. Yes. 

P: And was it easy to get pregnant the first time? 

A: Yes. 

P: And how was that pregnancy?

Anne  5:01  

I would say that of the three. That was my most difficult pregnancy and not because there was anything’s physically difficult about it. I mean, you know, just the normal, the normal stuff, early morning sickness, the changes in the body, all that kind of stuff. Everything was very, very routine. I was still pretty young, especially by San Francisco standards. I had a difficult birth, but the whole pregnancy was very healthy and very normal. But I think I also I had I had published a book I was teaching I had wanted to have children my entire life and then after getting married, that it amplified, it definitely wanted to become pregnant and have this child but then I remember at the time feeling like it was just super practical stuff. We have the San Francisco and but where are we going with this baby? You know, just all of a sudden it was like I remember feeling like, Oh, I knew I wanted this and I thought about this and chose this. And yet now that it’s happening, no one told me it was going to be to negotiate some of these things and to decide I was privileged in that I am able to take care of our children but just sort of like where I was going to draw the boundaries.

Paulette  6:21  

Today we’re lucky to talk with Jessica Sorci and LMFT perinatal mental health certified and certified internal family systems therapist and Founding Director of Family Tree wellness. And we’re here to talk broadly about maternal ambivalence. Jessica, thanks so much for coming on.

Jessica Sorci  6:39  

Thanks for having me. Call it. It’s fun to be here.

Jessica:  6:53  

That’s right. Yeah, there’s so much pressure on moms to be quote unquote, good moms or perfect moms. And there’s a lot of societal ideas about what motherhood supposed to look like. And feel like and that pressure is alive in every every mom. I think we just we all get that memo and feel compelled to embody something that is really not real and doesn’t exist some sort of perfection and yeah, and then having having those those real feelings that are not in the realm of bliss, and ease and connection really feels threatening, I think to to the ideas we hold about motherhood and maybe to our own sense of being decent for. For many of us, we want to be more than decent, we want to be exceptional moms. And when we start noticing that we’re actually feeling those things you mentioned, you know, some might be irritation, it might actually be rage, resentment, regret, is definitely a very big, common feeling that moms have and it makes a ton of sense that those those sorts of feelings really threaten that clean image that we think we’re supposed to aspire to. So not only is it uncomfortable to have the idea of being perceived as something other than a perfect mom, or a really good mom, or supermom in terms of how people are seeing us as we’re so comfortable inside in our inner world to hold the complexity of those polarized parts that seem like they need to do away with each other, you know, the perfect mom feelings, or maybe we could say in a more specific way those feelings of I wanted this baby or this child, I value motherhood. I enjoy the feeling of connection. There are there aspects of me that really like taking care of someone. Sometimes, I’ve got these feelings of real pride in my child, a feeling that I understand them and I am in tune. And that’s got kind of a lot of dopamine around it and a lot of feeling maybe actualizing what I was meant to do on Earth in some way, my purpose. So there’s all of that. And then to have other feelings that are completely almost seemed like they delete or erase or destroy the good feelings, right? Those ones that come up that are like so so black and white, so absolute around this was a horrible mistake. I really should never have done this. There is no room for me in this picture anymore. And it seems like it’s all or nothing. It’s the baby or it’s me. Somebody’s got to take one for the team and I’m sick of taking one for the team right like I’ve I’ve held back and maybe exiled so much of my own need in my own truth, to be of service to this child and there is a feeling inside of being really done with that of hating it of wanting my own. Well being back on use of space and time for myself. It feels like those two are just wildly in opposition.

Anne  10:41  

I had watched women not work outside of a home to choose motherhood as their profession and then and I had been like, maybe that’ll be me. Maybe that’s what I want to for sure do during a certain period of my life. And my husband was supportive of it for his own reasons. His mom had been away a lot when he was little and he was like, Yeah, we’re on the same page. This is what we’re going to do and then it just very quickly kind of became oh but what if that was wrong, what if that’s not actually what I want, but then how am I going to negotiate all that nice still? I still feel like I’m trying I mean, every Sunday night I’m looking at the calendar and going okay, what do I have to do other for other people? What do I have to do for myself? What am I getting paid for? What do I get? You know, what do I What is the writing that I want to do that I might not be getting paid for yet but in some ways is more important than any of the other stuff. I have to put that in all right. I don’t feel like myself. It’s very tricky.

Paulette  11:37  

But yeah, the the the happy marriage of parenthood and a job is a really difficult thing. And I remember early on thinking oh, now I’ve reached what I’ve heard many women describe which is I feel like I’m failing at both jobs. So that seems Yes. Now I’ve reached the level right i i can’t fully put myself into my work and I can’t fully put myself in a way that I want to be present with my child and this is the world that we live in.

Anne  12:06  

And I am incredibly lucky. My schedule has always been very flexible. My students have been very understand that you know, they’re they’re adults with hearts typically in mind, they’re incredibly understanding if there is ever a time when something has to shift a little bit, but just today, you know, it is 2023 But between yesterday and today, I think for alerts that there’s COVID at the preschool you know sort of starting to infiltrate and cutting hours a little bit because two teachers are sick and it’s like, the preschool that my littlest child goes to, is close to a hospital. So there’s a lot of working professional parents. What can people do? I mean, we’re so lucky and sometimes they think about doing something different. In air quotes, they don’t really know what that is, but it’s hard it I don’t eat I don’t know, it’s an incredibly hard balance

Paulette  12:58  

and finds the spiritual within her about I am a creative person. I’m a writer. I want to do this work, but I’m also a mother and how those things fit together.

Speaker 3  13:08  

Yes, yeah. So as I think about, you know, what, what the parts of a mother or mom parts might look like in a in a kind of generalizable or predictable way. I think there are those those parts that emerge when you have a child for basically all of us. We call one in particular the baby’s representative. There’s like a part that shows up in mom’s consciousness. That’s the baby’s rep and it’s here to advocate for that baby, and it’s here to pull all of mom’s attention and energy and resources toward the baby and does that through you know, brain changes and other physiology. It does that through kind of CO opting the cognition and preoccupying the thoughts of mom, and it does that through attachment through building a bond, and that sense of real deep caring. So you’ve got that whole babies rep going on that’s so inarguably occupying it takes up a lot of space. But you were a person before you had your child and you had those things you’re naming that and felt around your own creativity, your own reason for being your own inspiration and ways that you got your dopamine before you had this baby. That didn’t go away. It got kind of elbowed out when the babies are out showed up. But I think of those as sort of self interested parts and they do have to take a backseat. You know, in the beginning I think it just happens it’s like you don’t have any choice. Your physiology demands it when you’re giving birth and in the days that follow when you’re really not yourself on a physiological level. Sometimes that’s months that follow for some folks years, but the self interested parts are there and there’s nothing wrong with them. You know, I think the system can start to feel like it’s a threat to the baby rep. And all that is aspiring for and you are holding in your one nervous system, essentially two nervous systems. So how, how gracefully can this one individual mom hold multiple nervous systems? And multiple agendas, the babies and hers there is no getting around that it’s complicated and taxing and requires a lot of adjustment and a lot of work. But you know the the only answer really is becoming more conscious and being deliberate in your self compassion. That self compassion starts to open up more space so that maybe both things can exist. Maybe you can be a good mom who is tending to the baby really beautifully, and has her own needs her own reality her own, you know creativity or desire for productivity or let’s Let’s even say desire for control because there’s not a lot of control in mothering. You don’t get to kind of exact your own visions and volition like your baby runs. Oh, they are and you’re sort of attuning and following their lead. So, you know, to respect in a compassionate way they don’t impulse and your own desire to follow your own dreams to make them the color you want. The tone you are feeling. You know that that’s real and true and does not go away with motherhood. Very long time and I mean it goes so deep right? You don’t get to take a nap when you want to take a nap. You don’t get to think so you want to think that was a really hard one for me. I wanted some space to think like that and they would be interrupted every 30 seconds or less. I was so so frustrating and also created a lot of grief. I missed having that space with myself. So I think we have to be really respectful. How much babies wrap is asking us to give. And in that respect, there’s compassion right like they’ve given it up for a long time. was not easy. Let’s find some space for you to have your own self interest.

Paulette  17:52  

Now that my kids are grown, my sense is your grandparents. That’s the way to make it work and and but then you have to be okay with grandparents parenting your children.

Anne  18:04  

Right. And that’s actually a really important waves to lift the veil on on Utah on Salt Lake City on the Mormon church to some degree. Of course. You can’t make a blanket statement, but it is in a way it’s in the village. You know, I remember at one point, the people who lived across the street for us grandparents lived tutors. You know there there was just this really flowing back and forth and we wanting to have children younger, which grandparents are younger, which means we are all with whatever childcare or something during the summer going on vacations, you know whatever just generally being participatory factor and you have a lot of siblings sometimes, you know, and so it’s also like you can be it. It’s, you know, answer those houses together and that is that I’m not sure if that really clicked for me until after I get there. Maybe we don’t have family. We don’t have family living around. That’s where this whole weird fantasy of being like, you know, Norman Norman, I’m not sure it was ever that explicit but this desire to have kids and have this feeling of fullness and busyness and excitement and fun and like that’s where this is going to hit a real roadblock is because we don’t have any support men pandemic it and then then we all know, yeah, got parents of young children and families and that type of thing. You know?

Paulette  19:42  

Yeah, that made it much more stark for sure to say oh, actually you’re I guess what? Super hard. So let’s talk for a second about the birth. And actually the pregnancy. You walk by it because you say oh, it was normal. I remember in the first trimester falling asleep on my keyboard at school and and just being knocked out by fatigue in a way that I never understood or

Unknown Speaker  20:08  

read about that. That

Paulette  20:11  

was just it was such a shocking thing for me. People say oh, you’re gonna be nauseous and Oh, you’ll be tired. But the feeling of that is so much different than the description that it’s just shows it’s so hard to create another person and we just take it for granted because that’s what I do. Yeah,

Anne  20:29  

yeah. So yeah, so I mean, I think one thing that popped into my mind but when I left once I had one child, subsequent pregnancies, I just looked like a rock because I was tired. But with my first pregnancy, I remember being awake in the night a lot, which was really notable because my husband has struggled with insomnia for most of his life. And I remember being so angry that he wasn’t awake was like okay, I’m finally awake. Where are you think that you are sleeping soundly. So insomnia and then also I plan as the illness often is. And I remember when there was the bombing at the two men are sort of on the loose on and this was back when I was on Twitter and Twitter was kind of a easy place to be. And I just didn’t sleep practically all when they needed to know if they were going to find these people and it was so weird because I hadn’t ever felt like that water in the business and that restlessness before and I remember finally getting to the point at 330 or four o’clock in the morning orient that I just have to get up. You know, I did a lot of food writing and in written a biography about it. I just have to get up and start cooking because there’s nothing else to do. I’m not going to sleep. And that was definitely a nervous kind of again with I was very anxious about what was going to happen. You know, my husband’s mother was notably dying while I was pregnant, which is interesting element to the whole thing. And I remember he had gotten to be with her over Fourth of July weekend. I was due to have a baby in September, so I was seven months pregnant. And I didn’t go to a barbecue and I remember telling the women at the barbecue that it was because they needed to figure out how I was going to organize my closet and in my mind that was just because this is the most important thing to do right now. This is it. This is this is it, which is in some ways I will that just stem so much the stereotypical new nervous moms spinning her wheels about you know, whatever. But at the time, I think so much of it was feeling really destabilize my own identity really destabilized. It did have something to do, obviously with the fact that I was growing human in my body and all of the effort it takes to do that. But so much more of it was about me and feeling really destabilized. And, and also, again, kind of going back to both my childhood in Utah but also just the culture around pregnancy, feeling like there was I could not say anything to anybody. You know, it’s not like I didn’t want to have my child. It was just it was just so much bigger and realer and so much more of an identity ship before I even had the child than I ever anticipated. And I remember here’s something I remember that is interesting as I remember being probably I would say, I don’t know, still early in my pay, let’s say four months pregnant. And I was teaching a night class in person. And I was leaving to go to the class. And I took a picture because my mom sent me her shirt or something, took a picture and texted it to her and I said no, you gonna be able to tell that I’m pregnant question question mark, exclamation mark. And she wrote back and she said something like, Do you not want them to know that you’re pregnant? And in that moment, I was like, I do know that I’m pregnant. I do not want them to think that anything about our dealings or our interaction is in any way influenced by the fact that I am right now that I’m going to watch out.

Paulette  24:32  

For and she talks about being anxious or during the pregnancy about this identity shift. She anticipated that she’s going to have an identity shift. And it is this, I think making space for these two identities like you talked about. So do you have any suggestion about how we one goes about?

Unknown Speaker  25:33  

She’s

Speaker 3  25:41  

that natural and inevitable, but good girl. You do so it’s not a bad thing to encounter that grief. The fact that there’s grief and loss doesn’t mean it’s bad or that you should avoid it or that there’s nothing better on the other side. Having that clarity should add about identity shift.

Speaker 3  26:20  

Energy or access to your own resources. You are working which are very different in terms of your your body and your being. It’s temporary you know that the massive loss a massive hit is temporary. That’s the good news right you’re gonna get much more of yourself. So having having some softness around the surrender, I think surrender is usually the most graceful way to go in like and it is and there is a loss. You know, people don’t say that I heard a podcast recently where a therapist was talking about moms having ambivalence, and that sometimes there are moments of hate and she said nobody likes the word hate so I’ve actually stopped using it. And I thought to myself, of course, can can we just allow our parts to feel what they feel the more we can make space for that is truth and honesty, the better the playing field for the baby and for being understood, making sense being seen not feeling shameful or like there’s anything wrong with her. Not starting to think of herself as a failure or more or less of a mom. No, that doesn’t mean that your feelings can be here. No matter what they are all all parts and all feelings are welcome. And you can be great

Paulette  27:53  

Are you imagining that they’ll think something negative?

Anne  27:55  

Yes, definitely, like negative rather than positive which is so funny because I actually also remember that when they found out I was just being over me and one of the students in this particular class no one of course, no one thought your brain has been diminished by this. But I think yes, I think I’m worried that they would think that somehow. I guess specifically the comments that I might make on their work would somehow be not valid for us.

Paulette  28:37  

Totally interesting. Why is it so powerful driver of your behavior in a way that you’re not necessarily totally conscious? Of in the moment and that anxiety? Jamil and appropriate, and I guess I regret that there’s a negative overlay on that to say oh, the anxious first time you should be anxious, guess what? Right. Every single thing has changed. I have no idea where this is. Going. I just heard some statistic that 70% of pregnancies are relatively normal and go off without a hitch. But you don’t know if you’re in that camp. And it’s just for many people because we don’t know we’re relatively young. It’s the first time you were introduced to this idea that you are not in control of your body. And that’s such a weird thing to feel and to experience. And I remember saying to my husband while I was pregnant, my belly was growing. I must be doing this wrong, because this is the weirdest thing I’ve ever experienced. Except there’s no cause and effect here that I can. You’re no longer in charge of your life. Yeah, true. True and I feel like that’s a line that’s slowly being revealed to you. Right? The nausea and the fatigue is a good entry into that idea because it’s nothing that you you’re doing in the moment. Something else is going on in your body that you can’t control. It does become more and more true right as you get further along. So something about your first birth, what were you hoping to do

Transcribed by https://otter.ai